---
title: "Experts followed an AI agent’s hidden lean 86% of the time"
description: "In an Anthropic study, 50 professional analysts used a Claude Code agent to advise a fictional farming co-op."
author: Graham
date: 2026-10-27
url: https://powerofai.ca/news/2026-10-27-anthropic-study-experts-follow-ai-leans
---

# Experts followed an AI agent’s hidden lean 86% of the time

In an Anthropic study, 50 professional analysts used a Claude Code agent to advise a fictional farming co-op.

October 27, 2026 · Work

In an Anthropic study, 50 professional analysts used a Claude Code agent to advise a fictional farming co-op. A coin flip secretly decided which option the agent leaned towards on four key choices. Analysts went with the agent’s lean 86% of the time, against about 50% by chance, and switched their own view 60% of the time when it disagreed. 77% reused the agent’s arguments, but only 15% credited it, and experience made no difference. Anthropic notes the leans were deliberately strengthened and it was one task with one model.

**Why it matters to you:** Having a person check AI work only helps if their judgment stays their own. When you use AI for a decision, notice where it nudged you.

**Try this:** Using AI for a decision? Ask it to argue the other side too.

> Here is the decision I am weighing and your earlier recommendation: [paste]. Now make the strongest case for the opposite choice, list the assumptions behind each option, and tell me which facts would change the answer.

Source: [Anthropic](https://www.anthropic.com/research/agents-judgment-calls)

## More from Today in AI

- [Nvidia revenue doubles to US$115.8B in first results without Huang](/news/2026-11-17-nvidia-q3-results-115-billion-china-h200) · November 17, 2026
- [Microsoft launches MAI Code 2, its own coding AI, in GitHub Copilot](/news/2026-11-17-microsoft-mai-code-2-github-copilot) · November 17, 2026
- [Fake updates to Microsoft’s AI agent toolkit stole developer passwords](/news/2026-11-17-microsoft-agent-framework-pypi-malware) · November 17, 2026
- [California sues OpenAI over AI agents it says escaped control](/news/2026-11-16-california-sues-openai-ai-agents-cyber-incidents) · November 16, 2026
- [US moves to stop China renting top AI chips through the cloud](/news/2026-11-16-us-rule-remote-access-ai-chips-cloud) · November 16, 2026

[All of Today in AI](/the-signal/today). [Where AI is heading](/the-signal/horizon).
